Australian Author - Fiona McIntosh

Welcome to the new look Fiona McIntosh BB

Please note that we are upgrading the software. To report a bug, please click here
A new Step-by-Step Guide is here.

Forum Activity

We have 482 active members and 568 total members.

Our diligent members have made 23854 posts in 3083 total topics.

Welcome to our latest members, Nerian, Martine, Richardtracey, Samuelobrien, Palladium

Forums

Welcome, Guest. You are not logged in, click to login or register.

Forum Navigation

Forums -> Trinity Trilogy ->  Well... I finished it. *possible spoilers* topic">Hot topic Well... I finished it. *possible spoilers*

Hot topic Well... I finished it. *possible spoilers*

#21 - 10th Aug 2002 14:42:00

Member

Total Posts: 20

Last Online: 18th Sep 2002 18:29:00

Registered: 16th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

What a magnificent ending. Fiona, you sure know how to close an outstanding tale. So many times I've been disappointed by lacklustre endings that seem out of whack with the weave of the writing. Destiny ends perfectly. No tears, but a singing heart. Kudos to you.

The wise make proverbs and fools repeat them

Edited by: Isharya at: 8/10/02 2:51:12 pm

#22 - 10th Aug 2002 16:02:00

Member

Total Posts: 120

Last Online: 19th Sep 2002 21:27:00

Registered: 15th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

What can I say... the ending was not the end... Can you not see that?

All great novels at a place where there is more to the story..

I cannot wait for resurrection... Rebirth, Born again or whatever th next Tallinor novel will be.

Mark my words... there will be more... and if not we will create it in fan fiction and in our own minds...

I already have a plot or a zillion going on for future TOR meets Alyssa novels.

Fiona,

You have captured, hearts minds and imagination... you are a poet.

#23 - 10th Aug 2002 17:12:00

Forum Moderator

Total Posts: 903

Last Online: 1st Jun 2004 21:40:00

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Thank you all. It lifts my spirits to great heights to know that it gave satisfaction at the end. I think the ending to any book but especially to a trilogy must be powerful. And in fantasy I rather need them to leave us with a really huge sense of hope and wellbeing. I think those dancing bananas are fantastic by the way - more than enough thanks!
(grin)

#24 - 10th Aug 2002 22:35:00

Member

Total Posts: 210

Last Online: 23rd May 2004 18:45:00

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Fiona Now that I have finished this wonderful tale i fell I can join others on the board in saying THANKYOU. You treated us readers like we had brains and intelligence. The ending was an amazing heartstopper that fully resolved to tales started in the book while still leaving us with the imagination to see what happens next.

This series has beeen just a great enjoyment to read so once again

THANKS

#25 - 11th Aug 2002 21:38:00

Member

Total Posts: 225

Last Online: 1st Sep 2008 22:41:45

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Thoroughly enjoyed the book Fiona. Finished it Thursday but haven't felt like starting another one book yet. Normally start on a new series as soon as I have finished one but feel I need a break.

I was in two minds while reading it.....one the one hand I couldn't put it down, on the other I didn't want to pick it up to try and make it last longer.

Thank you Fiona for sharing your special world with us.

#26 - 11th Aug 2002 22:28:00

Member

Total Posts: 173

Last Online: 12th Jun 2004 17:03:24

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

I finished it yesterday. No tears, but definitely jerked the old heart strings. I don't think the actual events at the ending are as important as the response from the reader to them. It's clear that everyone has been greatly moved by the story and there's no greater compliment than that!


Life is a containment field for thought. (A Slatz original.)

#27 - 11th Aug 2002 22:32:00

Forum Moderator

Total Posts: 903

Last Online: 1st Jun 2004 21:40:00

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Bravo, Slatz. Reader response is the ONLY reason a book becomes one which 'works'.

#28 - 16th Aug 2002 15:46:00

Member

Total Posts: 307

Last Online: 11th Oct 2004 10:02:05

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

I finished it, on Tuesday actually but it has taken me this long to emotionally recover to the point where I feel I can comment without breaking down again.

Not really work has been flat out and I haven't had a chance to post anything here for about a week.

What can I say Fiona that hasn't already been said by the others (and much more poetically than I could ever manage I'm sure). All I'll say is thankyou.

By the way I didn't cry, not just because I'd already read the ending, but then I rarely cry (except of course for GGK books which get me all weepy no matter how many times I read them).

Again thanks for the wonderful read Fiona. you are an inspiration to us all.

#29 - 16th Aug 2002 16:17:00

Forum Moderator

Total Posts: 903

Last Online: 1st Jun 2004 21:40:00

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

I've been wondering where you are BH...have you seen the snapshot at the site? Anyway, thanks for the generous comments. I'm just happy it satisfied. Did knowing the end spoil anything?...you have me so intrigued!

#30 - 16th Aug 2002 18:01:00

Member

Total Posts: 120

Last Online: 19th Sep 2002 21:27:00

Registered: 15th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Fiona

Like the Big hilly fella i read the end page before the book itself, and Like I said before it doesn't really tell you what happens, read it yourself and you will see.

If I can tell what happens by reading the back page i dont read the book, if I can read a one page novel, the writer has been slack.
:hush

#31 - 21st Aug 2002 18:51:00

Member

Total Posts: 307

Last Online: 11th Oct 2004 10:02:05

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Fiona

I don't really pay that much attention when I read the last couple of pages first. As Steve says the last two pages shouldn't really tell you very much. I just do it out of habit really and of course so that if anything fatal should happen to me at least I will have died knowing how the book ended!

Really it's just like rereading a great book. Even knowing Valentin's secret and Diarmuid's fate does not in any way diminish the joy (not to mention constant wiping of eyes to stop page getting all blurry) of Tigana or Fionavar for instance.

#32 - 10th Sep 2002 18:41:00

Member

Total Posts: 104

Last Online: 10th Sep 2002 18:41:00

Registered: 15th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

lisa's package arrived at the end of last week and i finished it yesterday afternoon...

would have finished it sooner but i had to work each day that i had the book and had school on one of the days <img src=">

and the customers just arent respectful enough to not rent movies while i was reading.... the bastards(meant in the nicest way possible)

i had to clock out of work early because i was at the last 15 pages and each time i read a sentence another customer would come up to the counter... so i left work an hour and a half early, sat in my car with the air conditioning on and finished it.

Great book fiona ! <img src=">

and thank you so much for the book plate and note, it still amazes me that you keep such open communication with your readers <img src=">


ASTEROID B-612
AIM: LCHAOS1

#33 - 10th Sep 2002 18:42:00

Forum Moderator

Total Posts: 903

Last Online: 1st Jun 2004 21:40:00

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Lovely to hear from you CL and glad the book pleased in spite of your thoughtless customers!

I will never stop chatting to readers. They make all the hard work of writing float away.

#34 - 10th Sep 2002 19:36:00

Forum Moderator

Total Posts: 1680

Last Online: 21st Nov 2007 13:21:01

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Fiona will never stop talking to her fans... aren't we all lucky?

#35 - 24th Oct 2002 19:09:00

Forum Moderator

Total Posts: 903

Last Online: 1st Jun 2004 21:40:00

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Thank you, Crusie. This meant a lot to me. I could never hate Orlac either. When I first started writing Betrayal I had visions of him being pure evil yet charismatic. However, Goth really took over the villain role and I began to realise how Orlac was shaped through events and that he was as much a victim. I wanted to put him at odds within himself and I suppose Dorgryl became a great vehicle for that. And liking him - which I hoped the readers would by the end - was the reason I gave him a false name. The revealing of his true name meant a fresh start for him.

I'm fascinated by most people's belief that there are more stories here. I'm not sure I see them.

So everyone - I've started a new thread. Talk away, I'm intrigued.

#36 - 24th Oct 2002 19:58:00

Member

Total Posts: 326

Last Online: 26th Mar 2008 00:12:24

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Ok so belated but I got here. Yes I finally found some time to read and polished off destiny in the past couple of days.

Tears at the end? No. (I would admit them if I did)
I am not sure what I felt but it was a fitting end. Orlac always fasinated me and I never really got to hate him so it was easy to like him in the end. I felt sorry for Saxon and Cloot, the were the most loyal and they lost and gave up the most.
The childrens reactions were not fully explored and with so many characters it was hard to achieve a neat finish for all (a pretty good job of achieving that in limited space Fiona). I suppose the matchups were pretty obvious for some time and I saw them coming.
Perhaps it finished a little fast and I didn't feel a crescendo build up, though that didn't detract from my enjoyment of the book or series.

I agree this is just the beginning and if Fiona feels like going back someday there are so many more stories to write.


I am not that analytical, all I know is I like or I don't like. In this case I like.

Kudo's to Fiona on a wonderful trilogy and may it be the first of many.

..............................
a little less conversation
a little more action

#37 - 27th Oct 2002 00:16:00

Member

Total Posts: 63

Last Online: 13th Jul 2008 22:49:51

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

I've finished! What a wonderful read, thoroughly enjoyed it Fiona, many thanks.
I admit to feeling that the the ending was rather rushed or was that just me, trying to finish so I could get on with my mile-high stack of marking?

Spoiler ahead...
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
.
.
.
Poor Locky, Fiona couldn't you have set him up? I'm a romantic fool but Locky losing out to Rubyn was the saddest thing in the whole trilogy, especially afterall he'd been through *brings out the tissues and blows nose*. I hope he appears again in the future and 'hits the jackpot'.

Once again Fiona thanks, I lost myself in your world that, for me, is a sign of an excellent read.

#38 - 27th Oct 2002 19:37:00

Forum Moderator

Total Posts: 903

Last Online: 1st Jun 2004 21:40:00

Registered: 14th May 2004 00:00:00

Send Message?

Post: Reply | Quote

Wonderful!

No, the rush is definitely me or more to the point, the characters. I just get excited I think and I'm always galloping along anyway but when all those things were happening on top of one another, I couldn't help it - it was definitely a breathless hurtle to the end.


So glad you enjoyed and yes I felt Rubyn didn't perhaps deserve the gal but that's how it panned out. Poor Locky but you see if he tore at your heartstrings, that's a good thing. The character came to life for you. I'm thrilled.

You know if I'd contrived to make things sweet for Locky, readers would have seen through me and accused me of being Enid Blyton-ish and forcing happy endings for everyone!

But I do agree, he's a truly likeable fellow and deserved more after all that he'd gone through. Eryn's lot are a very sad family I realise.